October 5, 2010
The Boston Globe’s Scoop: Many Companies Can’t Do the Executive Pay Math
– Broc Romanek, CompensationStandards.com
Yesterday, the Boston Globe ran this breathless story at the top of page one. I went into it expecting an analysis about the judgment calls we all make in drafting compensation disclosure and thought there might be journalistic oversimplification as typically happens in the mass media. Some might say that pay disclosure is not necessarily a science, but an art.
However, one has to concede that math is still a science – and the Globe’s research certainly raises eyebrows about how seriously some companies are taking their pay disclosures. The Globe looked at about 210 local company proxy statements, adding up the columns in the summary compensation tables. It turns out that 55 times – at 34 companies – the totals of the columns did not match the number the company reported in the “Total” column. Um, that’s over 15%.
At most of these companies, the Globe determined (or the company conceded) that it was some sort of math or clerical error – transposed numbers, extra digits, etc. In some cases, when the company updated the stock compensation numbers for the past years using the SEC’s new methodology, they just changed the column in the middle of the table but didn’t update the total. Truly, the devil is always in the details and I would urge companies to double-check their numbers this year as I imagine a lot of newspapers are going to be following the Globe’s lead and do the math themselves in their local areas. Thanks to Mike Andresino of Posternak for bringing the article to my attention!