October 14, 2011
ISS Releases Final ’11 US Postseason Report
– Broc Romanek, CompensationStandards.com
Yesterday, ISS released its Final 2011 U.S. Postseason Report, which includes vote results for meetings held before September 1st, with findings that include:
– During 1st year of mandatory say-on-pay, investors overwhelmingly endorsed companies’ pay programs, providing 92.1% support on average.
– 38 Russell 3000 companies, or just 1.6% of the total that reported vote results, had their say-on-pay voted down. The primary driver of these failed votes appears to be pay-for-performance concerns, which were identified at 28 companies. Almost half of the failed-vote firms have reported double-digit negative three-year total shareholder returns. Also contributing to investor dissent were issues like tax gross-ups, discretionary bonuses, inappropriate peer benchmarking, excessive pay, and failure to address significant opposition to compensation committee members in the past.
– Investors overwhelmingly supported an annual frequency for SOP, with a majority (or plurality) support at 80.1% of companies in the Russell 3000 index, as compared to triennial votes, which won the greatest support at 18.5% of issuers.
– Management preferences did not appear to have a significant influence on the outcome of this year’s frequency votes. Investors had defied management recommendations for triennial votes at 538 of 892 Russell 3000 companies. Shareholders also were not swayed by biennial recommendations at 34 out of 47 Russell 3000 firms.
– The number of directors at Russell 3000 firms that failed to garner majority support fell by nearly half as say on pay votes presented shareholders with an alternative to votes against compensation committee members. Poor meeting attendance, the failure to put a poison pill to a shareholder vote, and the failure to implement majority-supported shareholder proposals were among the reasons that contributed to majority dissent against board members this year.
Only Two Weeks Until the Big Conference! ISS & Glass Lewis on 4 Different Panels!
As happens so often, there is now a mad rush for folks to register for our upcoming pair of say-on-pay conferences (one regarding disclosure and one regarding pay practices – both combined for one price). Come hear the views of ISS and Glass Lewis, as representatives will sit on a total of 4 panels during the two days of action. See the agendas.
Act Now: Come join 2000 of your colleagues in San Francisco – or thousands more watching live (or by archive) online – to receive a load of practical guidance and prepare for what is promising to be a challenging proxy season. Register now.