April 12, 2017
Shareholder Proposals: Can’t Exclude Confidential Pay Vote Tallies
– Broc Romanek
Recently, Corp Fin denied a no-action request from Celgene to exclude a shareholder proposal submitted by John Chevedden. The proposal sought a bylaw that would prevent the board from seeing a running vote tally when say-on-pay or shareholder approval of plans were on the ballot. The company made unsuccessful arguments under Rule 14a-8(i)(2) (arguing it was a state law matter) – and (i)(7) ordinary business. Over the years, Corp Fin has allowed exclusion of shareholder proposals that sought confidentiality for preliminary vote tallies for uncontested matters under (i)(7) – a broader plate of topics than the narrower “pay topics only” proposal at issue in this case.