November 18, 2026
Say-on-Pay: Largest Asset Managers Deviate More from Proxy Advisors & Each Other
As Liz shared in September, 2026 was a banner year for say-on-pay. One factor potentially driving the increase in support is that the “big five” investors are taking more independent views. Per Pay Governance:
The “big five” investors continue to take a selective approach to opposing S&P 500 SOP proposals and rely heavily on their proprietary voting frameworks. Top asset managers supported SOP at a rate of 95.6% in 2026 and deviated from proxy advisor SOP opposition in an overwhelming majority of cases.
Not everyone thinks this is a good thing. ICCR, together with the Center for Active Stewardship (CAS), recently studied this trend more thoroughly by looking at how the largest asset managers voted on the 27 say-on-pay failures from July 1, 2025, to June 30, 2026 and found that a few of the major asset managers supported a majority of the say-on-pay proposals that failed. From ICCR’s perspective, “If funds support CEO pay when the majority of votes are cast against, it could suggest guidelines are too lenient.”
For the corporate audience, the important takeaway from the ICCR research is that the largest asset managers are increasingly diverging from proxy advisor recommendations and from each other. Understanding where your largest shareholders are in the spectrum can help you plan accordingly. The ICCR blog shares this data on how some of the major U.S. asset managers voted on say-on-pay proposals that ultimately failed:
– Vanguard voted against 8/25 possible SoPs (32% alignment)
– State Street voted against 12/24 possible SoPs (50% alignment)
– BlackRock voted against 16/23 possible SoPs (70% alignment)
– Goldman Sachs voted against 5/24 possible SoPs (21% alignment)
– With 5 votes unknown, Citadel voted against none of the SoPs in the scorecard – indicating 0% alignment with the majority of shareholders
European asset managers and public pension funds, on the other hand, were very aligned with voting outcomes:
– Legal and General (voted against SoP in 22/22 possible votes)
– UBS (voted against 21/21 possible SoP votes)
– Amundi (voted against 16/16 known SoP votes)
– BNP Paribas (voted against 15/15 possible SoP votes)
– HSBC (voted against 13/13 possible SoP votes
– State Board of Administration of Florida System (voted against SoP in 19/19 known votes)
– Teachers Retirement System of Texas (voted against SoP in 16/16 possible votes)
– State of Wisconsin Investment Board (voted against SoP in 16/16 known votes)
– Maryland State Retirement & Pension System (voted against SoP in 15/15 possible votes)
– NY State Teachers’ Retirement System (voted against SoP in 12/12 possible votes)
For more detail, you can check the full scorecard.
– Meredith Ervine
Blog Preferences: Subscribe, unsubscribe, or change the frequency of email notifications for this blog.
UPDATE EMAIL PREFERENCESTry Out The Full Member Experience: Not a member of CompensationStandards.com? Start a free trial to explore the benefits of membership.
START MY FREE TRIAL